Ranking Every Olive Oil

Written By Manager MIN

Andrew goes full EVOO in this flavorful episode of Best with Babish, tasting his way through a lineup of olive oils from budget basics to fancy finishing bottles. Some are grassy, some are peppery, and some are just plain confusing—but only a few make the cut. Whether you're cooking, dipping, or drizzling, this episode helps you find your oil soulmate.

Here’s the ranking:

  • Lucini Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 10

  • 365 Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 9

  • Good & Gather Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 8

  • Frankies 457 Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 8

  • Pompeian Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 8

  • Graza Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 8

  • Botticelli Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 8

  • Cento Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 8

  • Cobram Estate Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 8

  • Spectrum Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 8

  • Trader Joe's Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 7

  • Sky Organics Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 7

  • Napa Valley Naturals Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 7

  • California Olive Ranch Extra Virgin Olive Oil -7

  • Gaea Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 7

  • Frankies 457 Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 7

  • Terra Delyssa Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 7

  • Montebello Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 6

  • Kirkland Signature Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 6

  • Brightland Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 6

  • Gem Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 6

  • Carapelli Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 6

  • Filippo Berio Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 6

  • La Tourangelle Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 6

  • Colavita Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 5

  • Centonze Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 5

  • Bartenura Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 5

  • Bertolli Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 5

  • Primal Kitchen Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 5

  • Partanna Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 4

  • Iberia 100% Extra Virgin Olive Oil & Blend - 3

Manager MIN
Previous

Ranking 46 Peanut Butters
Next

Ranking Every Aphrodisiac Food (feat. Lie Detector Test)