Ranking Every Vanilla Ice Cream

In this chilly episode of Ranked with Babish, Andrew Rea takes on a blind taste test of vanilla ice creams to determine which pint delivers the best classic scoop. From budget buys to premium pints, he ranks each one without knowing the brand. It’s a creamy, cold-hearted battle for vanilla supremacy.

Here’s the ranking:

• McConnell's - 8

• Edy's French Vanilla - 8

• Cool Haus - 7

• Ben and Jerry’s - 7

• Turkey Hill - 6

• Lactaid - 6

• Van Leeuwen - 6

• Häagen-Dazs Vanilla Bean - 5

• Blue Bunny - 5

• Häagen-Dazs Vanilla - 5

• Tillamook - 5

• Nick's - 4

• Breyers Homemade Vanilla - 4

• Oat-ly! - 4

• Halo Top - 4

• Breyers Natural Vanilla - 4

• Breyers French Vanilla - 4

• Righteous Gelato - 3

• Adirondack - 3

• Talenti - 3

• Arctic Zero - 2

• Blue Marble - 2

• Edy's Vanilla Bean - 1